The Things I Cannot Change

Tanya Ballantyne,
1967,
55 min 5 s

Achetez en DVD

Synopsis
Point de vue
Éducation

This film is considered to be the forerunner of the NFB's Challenge for Change Program. It is a look at the Bailey family, as seen from the inside. Trouble with the police, begging for stale bread, the birth of another child, and through it all, the father who tries to explains his family's predicament. Although filmed in Montreal, it's the anatomy of poverty as it occurs throughout North America.

Extrait de la sélection : Challenge for Change

Things I Cannot Change is not, strictly speaking, part of the CFC/SN program. While it is often held-up as the first film under the Challenge for Change banner and discussed as key component of the program's legacy, the film was completed as a pilot project and broadcast on CBC prior to the formal launch of CFC. It stirred a great deal of controversy with regards to the treatment of the poverty-stricken family at the centre of the film. According to contributor Marit Kathryn Corneil, "the outrage this caused at the NFB inspired some producers and filmmakers to rethink the ethics of documentary filmmaking in the context of community development, and this became the agenda for the experimental program in ethical documentary at CFC/SN."

— Thomas Waugh, Ezra Winton, Michael Baker

Les évaluations professionnelles et les guides pédagogiques sont réservées aux abonnés CAMPUS.

CAMPUS

Des fonctionnalités conçues spécialement pour les profs!

En savoir plus Déjà abonnés? Connectez-vous.

Commentaires

«I would like to know when Mr and Mrs Bailey passed away... And if all the adult children did well after Courage to Change... Also, the lady who was in the hospital, is she doing well???» — HBennett, 16 Sep 2012
«I am the daughter of the 4th oldest born...I love this film I can watch it over and over to see my aunt uncle and mom when they where little.I love seeing my grandparents i miss them very so much <3 :-( » — CynnBailey, 20 Avr 2012
«These are my grandparents :) This video is very sad to watch. I don't remember my Grandfather , but I know he was an amazing guy and a good cook :)My grandmother in this video passed away not to long ago .. she was a really great person and I miss her a lot , I still see all my aunts and uncles but not much since they live far from me ... This video mean's so much to me and I love watching it and seeing my great family <3» — Awhite97, 20 Avr 2012
«i am the son of 1 of the kids i this movie and i want to no where to find the courage to change i really want to no the history of my family and i cant find it anywhere» — cbailey, 27 Fév 2012
«This couple have such a love and respect for each other. This man loves his family so much, is so patient with the children no matter what is going on in his life. I hope that he and his wife found some relief, some joy for themselves and their children. They have such dignity and integrity within the difficulties of their lives and celebrate the new baby, even though it means more pressure to provide. Blessings to all of the children and their children forever. » — Buttons, 21 Fév 2012
«Someone please tell me where i can find the second video to this, The Courage to Change?» — bajangal, 27 Jan 2012
«I am the granddaughter of Kenny's sister. I do not know my Great Uncles children. My understanding is that this film has been a painful smear for our families for many years and, in ways, continues to be. Never having known of the film, I came across it at age 19 on television. It was a shock. My heart goes out to my kin as they age with this film in their past, created without their control or consent...Im sure it has been an extremely heavy and, at times, painful burden. » — Pictures, 20 Nov 2011
«Amazing to see this film again after so many years. We watched it at school around 1971 when I would have 11. It was enough to keep me from wanting to have children. Such utter misery. Some of the comments express pity for the father. I just felt sorry, scared and horrified for the children that were born to this poor ignorant couple who didn't equate too many children with poverty. Tragic.» — cinecritic, 27 Sep 2011
«wow this was sad to watch you can look in the husbands eyes of how much he wants to support his family and cant and while tryin to make a little living some jerk refused to pay him and winds up beatin him up, it was clear to see he was the victim all he wanted was his $6. It was not fair how all these witness was there and that criminal got away with beatin the poor man. It seems like history is still in our present cus people are still gettin wrongly accuse of crimes that they didnt commit.» — Anastasia, 4 Fév 2011
«I am the 11th child born and was in the second movie "the Courage to Change". » — JBailey, 22 Oct 2010
«This film is about my family. I'm the 10th child being born. » — HBailey1966, 6 Oct 2010
«Yes - the sequel was called Courage to Change.» — jmatlin, 7 Sep 2010
«Wasn't there a sequel made? it is an excellent doc , one of the best!» — allseeingeye, 6 Sep 2010
«This is so sad how these people lived in Montreal back 1967. I was 11 yrs old when this took place and recall we went to Expo 67 that year. I am guessing this family never even went to Expo 67. Makes me want to cry! Poverty is a cancer in soceity» — Trig_Professor, 6 Jui 2010